Vulnerable man faces extradition
from various sources
4WardEver UK – 28th Dec 2009
Updates on this case listed at the foot of this item
Gary McKinnon is facing a lengthy sentence in a US jail for hacking into Pentagon and NASA systems from his home in London. Gary has been diagnosed with Asperger’s syndrome, a form of autism, and his lawyers argued, in an appeal to the European Court of Human Rights, that because of this, and because the crime was committed on British soil that he should be tried here in the UK.
Gary’s mother Janis Sharp has described the 43-year old as ‘broken and suicidal’ and experts have warned he could take his own life if extradited. A medical report said Gary has a “fixed-psychological conviction he will kill himself in preference to being extradited”. The study by consultant psychiatrist Professor Jeremy Turk of St George’s Hospital, said that suicide was now an “almost certain inevitability”.
Details of the report emerged following a decision by Alan Johnson, the Home Secretary, not to block the extradition on medical grounds. Mr McKinnon’s distraught mother said Mr Johnson, “should hang their heads in shame” over the extradition to face hacking charges.
Protracted extradition proceedings have “turned Gary into a nervous wreck” who is on medication to quell his suicidal tendencies, his mother, Janis Sharp, told MPs yesterday. In the light of Gary McKinnon’s hearings, the chairman of the Home Affairs Select Committee has questioned whether the Human Rights Act is fit for purpose. The Human Rights Act is so exacting that Gary McKinnon’s risk of suicide might not be sufficient to engage its protections and prevent his extradition.
The threat of extradition was having a detrimental effect on McKinnon’s mental health, said Janis Sharp, his campaigning mother. She told MPs on the Home Affairs Select Committee: “It has ruined Gary’s life… it has destroyed him. If the door goes, he jumps. If someone touches him, he jumps. He has incredible chest pains every morning.”
It is reported that Gary became suicidal after the High Court threw out his appeal against extradition on human rights grounds. He was put on medication. “He would rather be dead than be extradited, that’s the reality,” his mother said.
Mark Lever, head of the National Autistic Society, told MPs that extradition, by taking an Aspergic far from familiar surroundings and family, could have a severe effect on their mental health.
in November 2009 Home Secretary stated that the Government would not intervene to block Gary McKinnon’s extradition. Liberty director Shami Chakrabarti said: “A government can’t tie its own hands and then protest that its hands are tied. The shoddy treatment of this vulnerable man should demonstrate that our rotten extradition laws need urgent reform.”
Liberty argues that where conduct constituting a crime occurs in the UK then a British court should be allowed to refuse extradition if it is in the interests of justice to do so. Liberty also holds that the requesting country should have to make out the case for extradition in a British court before the request is granted.
This change in decision followed the Home secretary’s initial halt on proceedings in October 2009 to consider new medical evidence about the computer hacker’s mental state. He had asked Home Office lawyers to consider the implications of fresh evidence about Gary’s state of psychiatric health.
Gary’s mother said: “I am extremely pleased Alan Johnson is doing this. I am sure that when he sees such strong evidence he will realise he should intervene and stop the extradition.
“Even at this late stage I hope when confronted with such compelling-evidence he will show the compassion that the people of this country are longing to see. Gary is pleased and relieved. It is the best news he has received for a long time and it gives him some hope.”
Liberal Democrat leader Nick Clegg said: “The Home Secretary has sat on his hands for too long, even in the face of legal advice from leading advocates that contradicts the Home Office’s position.”
Mark Lever, head of the National Autistic Society said: “We are bitterly disappointed by the Home Secretary’s decision and feel hugely sympathetic towards Gary and his family who have now been living under extreme stress for a prolonged period of time.
People with Asperger syndrome are often much more vulnerable than appearances would suggest and can be highly susceptible to additional mental health problems. On the strength of recently submitted medical evidence and the support of the Home Affairs committee, we had hoped that Mr Johnson would listen to these concerns.”
Hacker Gary McKinnon will not face UK charges
14 December 2012
UK hacker Gary McKinnon wins extradition battle
16 October 2012
Home secretary in a spot over hacker’s extradition to US
16 December 2009
Hacker denied extradition appeal
9 October 2009
Failing McKinnon and failing us too
31 July 2008
Profile: Gary McKinnon
30 July 2008